Page 1 of 3
Someone tell me I'm confused
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 2:07 pm
by kmv
If:
VCA Rules wrote:5. Members must not have any completely "non-anime" video entries. Members who have created a catalogue entry where all of the "anime" listed is actually "non-anime"... <snip>
and:
Video Info: Road to Iron Chef wrote:Anime(s):
- Back to the Future
- Fargo
- Homestarrunner.com - Strongbad Emails
- Last Action Hero
- Original Drawings
- Spice World: the Movie
Then how can:
Nominees by video wrote:Road to Iron Chef, AbsoluteDestiny (Ian Roberts)
- Best Comedy Video
- Best Parody Video
be?
Is this a mistake or do BBT's drawings count as anime?
Don't get me wrong guys (AbsoluteDestiny, Akimbo, Big Big Truck, Kusoyaro), I think this is a great video - I just didn't think it was anime.
Hoping someone can point out my error (and hoping I haven't just stepped on a hornets nest).
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 2:21 pm
by VegettoEX
In all honesty, I love all of the people involved with that particular video, I look up to them and ask for their advise, and laugh my ass off, still, when I watch it...
But I kinda agree.
Maybe it's a little bit of favoritism, maybe it's a little bit of misunderstanding, but technically I don't believe it follows the guidelines for being included in the database. I made a video with <I>Mortal Kombat II</I> footage back in 2000, but I would never list it on this site... it's not an AMV. I guess you could argue that in this case, the video is its "own anime" and directly reflects the AMV community, its members, AMV creation, etc... so there's definitely two sides to it.
It's up to the fans to vote for the "best" video in each category. If you don't feel that <B>RtIC</B> is the "best" parody video by going by the <B>category's description</B> (this is key, here)... then don't vote for it. If you <B>do</B> feel it best fits the description and you prefer it to the other videos, by all means, vote for it.
I totally understand the daunting task of weeding out all the non-anime videos, and hope there will be a more streamlined definition and enforcement in the future... until then, I totally sympathize with Phade and the admins that have to deal with all that stuff ^^;;
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 2:33 pm
by Scintilla
I remember reading somewhere a statement that EK's drawings counted as anime for being-allowed-to-stay purposes.
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 3:41 pm
by Jebadia
I thought Phade just wanted it on the org because it was as semi-clever and fun to watch docu-parody.
Anywho, it's funny and all..but those factors do leave it to be disqualified, no matter who made it. EK's drawings shouldn't be the reason to allow it in either. And with saying that shouldn't AD's vids be disqualified for having an all none-anime source vid (though collaborative) listed on the database?
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 3:46 pm
by Flint the Dwarf
Technically, I'd say yes.
But it's too late now.
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 3:48 pm
by Pie Row Maniac
Wow. This never came to mind before reading this.
And sadly, I do have to agree. Despite it being a funny video, it is technically non-anime so to be fair (unless the site's trying not to) it should be off the VCA listings.
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 4:18 pm
by Arigatomina
I noticed that as well, back when creators were being disqualified. But think about it. An admin helped make the video (and it's listed as his in the VCA's). You can't expect him to disqualify his own video. ^_^;;
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 4:29 pm
by Beowulf
People. There is a heirarchy.
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 5:16 pm
by Scintilla
Arigatomyna wrote:I noticed that as well, back when creators were being disqualified. But think about it. An admin helped make the video (and it's listed as his in the VCA's). You can't expect him to disqualify his own video. ^_^;;
Why not, if it breaks the rules?
Though no one's yet issued an official statement as to whether or not this really is technically rule-breaking...
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 5:46 pm
by Arigatomina
It doesn't break the rules because Phade said he was making certain exceptions on the 'no non-anime' rule when he started the deletions. I know he didn't say exactly which vids he was keeping, but he said a few of his favorites would be left up because he wanted them there. And since this one is not only still up, but being counted in the site's *anime* contest - I'd say it's one of his favorites. So it isn't breaking any rules (Phade sets the rules).
And what I meant by saying the admin couldn't delete his own vid was that someone above him would have to do it. And Phade already said he wanted to keep some non-anime vids, so he isn't going to.